![]() |
![]() |
|
The Theory of Shoe Tilt
Introduction: The following sections on shoe tilt are very speculative. Although in my mind, I can picture a horseshoe spinning only in a particular angle plane (or tilt) all the way down to the other stake; in practice, I don't know that anyone would exert the type of force on the shoe that would cause this to occur. So these sections are more for speculation and theoretical thinking. Some benefit may be realized by thinking about the theory of shoe tilt (especially in section 18C in the discussion on improper lift throwing off the alignment of the horseshoe). I do not deny that there is a tilt when the shoe is released. I'm just not sure in practice that any pitcher would spin the shoe to maintain a particular "path tilt" angle. In practice, horseshoes seem to tumble with the shoe spinning in the position the shoe was in at the point of release (i.e. both heel calks up, one particular heel calk up and the other down, both heel calks down, etc.). Turning shoes tend to have a predominant amount of horizontal motion in the turn as opposed to vertical motion (or more motion in the angle of the upward path of the shoe) that conforms with gravitational pull versus vertical lift beyond the upward path of the flight of the horseshoe. As discussed elsewhere on this page, too much vertical lift in relation to the upward path of the shoe will cause the shoe to flip or turn over. I originally did not have these sections on shoe tilt highlighted with "yellow" colored background and did not have the introduction above preceding the sections. After receiving an email from someone saying they did not follow exactly what I was trying to say concerning shoe tilt, I thought some more about it and realized that much of what I was thinking and writing about on shoe tilt was not that practical, but nonetheless interesting from a theoretical standpoint. Again, I emphasize that I'm not trying to sound like a know-it-all, I'm just expressing thoughts that are going on in my mind when I think on these things. I think the physics of horseshoe pitching is fascinating and very interesting to think about. SHOE TILT AND SHOE LIFT (THE UPWARD PATH) ![]() This
would explain why pitchers who put a side
lift on a shoe improperly, often find their shoe heading for the right
or left side of the stake. They began on their upward swing with
the center of the shoe heading for the stake, but an improperly applied
side lift “pulled” the center to the right or left slightly.
Looking at the drawing at the left (viewed from behind the pitcher and
looking down court), HS1 (horseshoe #1 position) with the D1 (direction
of the center of the shoe to the stake) is thrown off course if the
left side of the shoe is lifted (heel calks) with a pivot on the right
side of the shoe (toe calk), with HS3 the position of the shoe upon
release and D2 is the new direction of the center--to the left of the
stake. If the toe calk had been dropped as the heel calks
were lifted, then HS2 would have been the release position of the shoe
beginning at HS1 and the center of HS2 would still be in line with the
stake (note: the right half of the shoe in HS2 moved to the right
as the shoe HS1 was lifted to position of HS2, keeping the center on
course.) It doesn't take much visualization to see what would
happen in the drawing to the left, if when the shoe is lifted from HS1
to HS3 with the heel calks to the left moving straight forward instead
of the toe calk moving straight forward that the center would be pulled
to the right for a right handed horseshoe pitcher, thus causing the
center of gravity of the shoe to head to the right of the stake
or to the right of direction D1. All of this is to illustrate
that the pitcher must not alter the course of the center of the shoe
during any lifts placed on the shoe.All shoes have at least a little lift or drop in the shoe (in relation to the upward path of the thrown horseshoe) except for one particular delivered shoe. The exception is the shoe that is completely in the delivery plane at the bottom of the swing already in the correct Up Path Tilt position. The full upswing of the shoe would have to keep the shoe on this delivery path plane with only turn rotation motion placed on the center of the shoe and no lift (in relation to the delivery path) needed on the shoe. This is what I’ve referred to as a Up Path Tilt shoe. If the pitcher can hold the shoe at the bottom of the swing and apply only revolution turn motion around the center of gravity of the shoe that is in the delivery plane only, the shoe will travel only in the delivery plane without any lift, thus maintaining its Up Path Tilt. Even a Level Tilt shoe will need a little lift in back in order to maintain its level position during flight along a delivery path that is slanted up and out. This is where all of this gets a little confusing. We are discussing Tilt and Lift in relation to the path of the released shoe, not to ground level. Also, we are discussing the path of the released shoe as a line when we are referring to the center of the shoe traveling on the line and we refer to the path of the released shoe as a plane when we are referring to the whole shoe measuring a maximum of 7-1/4 inches wide and 7-5/8 inches long. (Note: If a shoe is thrown with no turn rotation, but only lift, then it is a flip shoe and had better be open upon release if it is to have a chance of going on as a ringer.) To help visualize the horizontal and vertical plane that heads straight for the stake at release point of the shoe, picture a little 8 inches wide miniature highway going from the release point of the hand heading up and out from the pitcher, coming to a peak high point where the shoe then begins it's descent down towards the stake. This little 8 inches horizontal highway would end about 4 inches up the stake from the bottom of the pit and the middle of the stake would be dead center in the middle of this little highway. The vertical delivery plane referred to in this writing would be a little 8 inches high wall that would intersect this horizontal highway right down the middle and would end with the bottom of the wall in the pit and the top of the wall 8 inches up the stake. The delivery path "line" to the stake is where these two planes--the horizontal highway and the vertical wall--intersect. Most horseshoe pitchers who desire to throw an Up Path Tilt shoe will not be able to have the shoe at the bottom of the forward swing beside the leg in the exact horizontal highway that leads to the stake; therefore, they will have to apply some lift to get the shoe in the Up Path Tilt position at the point of release. But then the lift in the shoe will cause it to become an Up Tilt shoe before it reaches the high peak of it's flight. Therefore, if an Up Path Tilt shoe is desired at the high peak of it's flight, the proper lift will need to be applied and something closer to a Level Tilt, Down Path Tilt or a Down Tilt will have to be released with the lift on it to make it an Up Path Tilt shoe sometime during it's flight. In 18E section below, I explain the wrist motion I use to try to counter or reduce the lift influence on my shoe I want at the peak of it's flight. Too much lift influence on the shoe and the pitcher will be looking at a vertical leaning shoe at some point in it's flight. This shoe is discussed in section 19 below. SHOE TILT AND SHOE LIFT (THE DOWNWARD PATH) ![]() 18D The yellow “Downward Path of the Released Shoe” chart shows what all five of the tilts during the “Upward Path of the Released Shoe” look like during the downward path. I believe the pitcher should strive to throw a shoe tilting between the Up Path Tilt and the Down Path Tilt; and maybe ideally the Level Tilt at the peak high point of the flight of the horseshoe. I further believe the Up Tilt and Down Tilt shoes (tilting above or below the upward path and the downward path) will be less stable shoes during flight and landing, especially the more degrees they are thrown above the Up Path Tilt or below the Down Path Tilt. All of this discussion on the tilt and lift on a horseshoe is to impress on the horseshoe pitcher that nothing mysterious begins happening to a horseshoe once it leaves the hand of the pitcher. All of this discussion is to explain that what is taking place with the shoe during the forward swing and especially from the leg on up to the release of the horseshoe, while it is still in the pitcher's hand, is what determines the type of flight the shoe will have. |


Some
may cross over with the stepping foot in front of the stable foot, but
then compensate their swing to make up for this movement. I
suspect, most good pitchers will tell the novice to be sure and place
the bulk of the pitcher's body weight on the stable foot throughout the
delivery until that moment when the weight shifts to the stepping
foot. This allows the balance to be maintained throughout the
entire delivery process. A smooth step in the timing is what
helps keep the horseshoe on its original course. A sudden drop
onto the stepping foot is very likely to jar the shoe from its straight
path to the stake and throw the shoe to the left or right of the
stake. Even with the "square" delivery, there is room for
variation amongst pitchers. Some will tell you it is easier for
them to stand straight throughout the step forward. Others will
say it is more natural to bend forward and lean into your step.
Each pitcher should experiment with what is most comfortable with
them. Other variations are that some pitchers will use more of a
"set" delivery method, by holding the shoe up close to their face and
then swing back and forward and then let it fly. Others will use
what Dan Kuchcinski and others refer to as the "rhythm" delivery.
That is, they might begin by holding the shoe out in front of them, but
then they swing the shoe back and forth (sometimes the other arm swings
right along with the pitching arm) until it feels right to let it go;
or they may have a delivery where they swing back and forth a given
number of times (say 3) and then delivery it. Again, the best
advice is to not be afraid to experiment with each method to see which
one is the most comfortable with each pitcher. Studying the
illustration above (or to the left for lefties), one can see that any
pitcher who tells you to point your feet directly at the stake at the
opposite end, if that is precisely what they do; must swing their arm
not quite exactly square with their shoulder, else they would throw 6
inches or so to the right of the stake (for a right-hander) or 6 inches
or so to the left of the stake (for a left-hander). (Or whatever
measurement the swinging shoe is from the center of the planted
foot). If one is actually trying to use the "square" delivery,
where the shoulders always maintain that square with the swinging arm,
then the planted foot would actually point about 6 inches or so to the
left of the stake (if a string was run down the court from the middle
of the planted foot). Again, it must be emphasized here that
whatever works should be used for each pitcher, but in order to discuss
one such method, parameters must be set and adhered to in order to stay
within that system! I have seen videos of world champion pitchers
who lean slightly over toward the swinging arm and it sure works for
them. The key is that whatever each great pitcher does, they
consistently do it nearly 80% to 85% of the time. Awareness of
what one is actually doing is the first step to developing one's own
timing and rhythm. And it is this same awareness that allows good
pitchers to make immediate corrections when they miss the stake.
The discussion here was intended for explaining one such delivery
system to show what is being worked out by the great pitchers.
The rest of us just step up there and swing one way and step another
way and release at different points and do all of this at various
speeds and expect the same results pitch after pitch. When we do
this "consistently", we do get the same results, we miss
repeatedly. IT JUST DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY IF ONE IS TO BECOME A
GOOD CONSISTENT PITCHER WHO HITS A HIGH PERCENTAGE OF RINGERS! I've seen world champion pitchers look
down first at their feet in relation to the pit beside them to assure
themselves that they are starting everything correctly before they ever
look down at the opposite peg. I get the impression that they
could probably put on a blindfold at this point and out pitch the rest
of us. Because their "form" takes over once they are positioned
right in the beginning. Form merely being that thing which they
are able to do over and over again without breaking out of it.
![]() |
Official Web Site of the
Curt Day
Horseshoe Courts. A Web Site for the Horseshoe Courts named
after and in
honor of the career of 18 times Indiana State Champion & 3 times World Champion Curt Day. Located
at Dorner Park, Frankfort, Indiana. |